The distribution waterfall, tier by tier
A $100M fund makes four deals. As each one exits, its proceeds pour down four tiers and drain into two tanks: one for the investors, one for the manager. Switch between the two common styles and watch when the manager gets paid.
The four tiers. First, investors get their capital back. Second, they get the preferred return on it. Third, the manager catches up until it holds its carry share of the profit paid so far. Fourth, everything left is split, here 80/20.
What to try. Play the European style and stop at year 3: the manager has been paid nothing, because the fund has not yet returned its capital. Switch to American at the same year: the manager already holds $7.5M of carry from Deal A alone. Run to the end and the American manager has been paid $17.5M against $15.5M earned on the whole fund, so $2.0M is owed back. That gap is the clawback, and it exists because Deal B lost money after carry on Deal A had been paid.
Then make every deal a winner. The two styles pay the same total and the clawback disappears. The difference between them is timing and who carries the risk in between.
Simplified on purpose: all capital is called at year 0, the preferred return compounds annually, the catch-up is 100% to the manager, and there are no fees, recycling, escrow or loss carry-forward. The deals are invented for illustration and are not from any fund.